Lawsuit filed to block AMNH expansion


Make text smaller Make text larger


Local group claims Gilder Center project “would cause catastrophic environmental damage”


Photos



  • The American Museum of Natural History’s proposed Gilder Center expansion would occupy a quarter-acre of what is now Theodore Roosevelt Park. Rendering: AMNH




By Michael Garofalo

The next chapter in the long-running conflict between the American Museum of Natural History and opponents of the museum’s Gilder Center expansion plan will take place in court.

A lawsuit filed by a local group that opposes the museum’s plan to build the 200,000-foot center, part of which would occupy what is now a quarter-acre open space in Theodore Roosevelt Park, claims that if completed, the project would “not only result in the loss of public parkland comprising cherished greenspaces in Theodore Roosevelt Park, but worse, [...] would cause catastrophic environmental damage to the area, posing a series of life-threatening health hazards to residents of, and visitors to, the Upper West Side of Manhattan.”

The American Museum of Natural History received approval for the $340 million project from the Parks Department in December 2017, following a lengthy environmental review process. Plans call for the Richard Gilder Center for Science, Education, and Innovation to be built on the west side of the museum, facing Columbus Avenue near West 79th Street. Museum officials say the center will include new classrooms and exhibition spaces and improve visitor circulation within the museum complex.

Community United to Protect Theodore Roosevelt Park, the group that filed the lawsuit, argues that the project should have been subject to the city’s Uniform Land Use Review Procedure because it would occupy city-owned parkland outside of the portion of Theodore Roosevelt Park that Community United claims the museum is authorized to use. In its statement of findings on the project, the Park Department found that an 1876 state statute set aside the entire site of Theodore Roosevelt Park for the museum, and “no further legislative action or disposition of property is required for the Gilder Center project.”

Community United claims that in granting its approval, the Parks Department failed to adequately consider adverse impacts that could occur as a result of the project, including construction noise, impacts to transit and pedestrian safety as a result of a new museum entrance facing Columbus Avenue, and the potential release of hazardous materials during construction. The suit argues that the Parks Department “irrationally fails to recognize the significant adverse impacts of the Project, or where it does recognize such adverse impacts, arbitrarily accepts grossly inadequate and incomplete mitigation measures.”

The lawsuit names the city, the museum, the Parks Department and Parks Commissioner Mitchell J. Silver as respondents.

Museum officials aim to complete the Gilder Center by 2021. Community United seeks a court order preventing the museum from undertaking work on the project while legal proceedings are ongoing.

“At a time when science literacy has never been more important the Gilder Center will provide significant new capacity to enhance the public understanding of science,” a spokesperson for the museum wrote in an emailed statement. “We don’t have a specific comment on the lawsuit since we don’t comment on pending legal cases.”

A Parks spokesperson directed inquiries to the city’s Law Department. “The city stands by its approval of the Museum’s expansion plans and its environmental review,” Law Department Press Secretary Nick Paolucci wrote in an emailed statement. “We’ll review the legal papers.”





Make text smaller Make text larger

Comments



MUST READ NEWS

Image Court rules against UWS nursing home
Appellate court finds proposed 20-story nursing home on West 97th Street would violate open space zoning rules; appeal to state’s highest court likely to follow
Image Melee follows GOP club event
NYPD under scrutiny for response to violence following Gavin McInnes event; police seeking 12 individuals
Image Our brother’s keeper

It’s not a smoke-filled back room; it’s a second floor, badly fluorescent-lit space. There aren’t any cigars, just a large bag of pretzels shared...

Image “Grammar Zen”
New Yorkers talk tricky tenses, punctuation passions and more at Ellen Jovin's UWS pop-up table

VIDEOS



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Neighborhood Newsletters





MOST READ

Local News
Our brother’s keeper
  • Oct 16, 2018
Local News
The secrets of secretions
  • Oct 17, 2018
Local News
200 Amsterdam heads to court
  • Oct 19, 2018
Local News
Rally protests developers’ influence
  • Oct 16, 2018
City Arts News
Man about town
  • Oct 19, 2018

MOST COMMENTED